Manchester United’s Robin van Persie tops the Premier League scoring charts with 16 goals, while Liverpool Luis Suarez occupies second spot with 15. But who has been the best player so far this season?

Once again, Goal.com‘s Carlo Garganese and Peter Staunton take to the debating ring to have their say. Carlo’s in Suarez’s court, while Pete is in full support of Van Persie, but who do you side with?

Leave your opinion in the comment box below.